MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — A proposal to ban transgender students from playing on sports teams of the gender they identify with drew criticism during a public hearing on Thursday. The bill failed to advance in the House committee.
The bill titled the Gender Is Real Legislative Act, or GIRL Act, would have required student-athletes to compete under “the gender assigned at their birth," said the bill's author, Republican Rep. Chris Pringle. The bill would ban K-12 schools from allowing trans athletes to compete under their gender identity unless the event was co-ed.
Pringle said it's unfair for girls to compete against athletes “born and raised with the benefit of testosterone in their system."
“It in no way prevents transgender athletes from competing in athletic events. It just says they have to compete under the gender assigned at their birth," Pringle said.
The public hearing on the bill only drew opponents.
Carmarion D. Anderson, Alabama state director of the Human Rights Campaign, said the bill stigmatizes transgender individuals for something that has not been proven to be a problem. Anderson said a small percentage of people identify as transgender and “not all of them are interested in playing sports and even fewer of them are elite level."
“This bill targets transgender and gender non-conforming youth which is discriminating, plain and simple," Anderson said. “Transgender people are people. Transgender men are men. Transgender women are women."
The vote for the Gender is Real Legislative (GIRL) Act failed due to lack of motion. As a result, the bill dies and will not move forward to become law.